Skip to main content
​18th March, 2015
​
​
CIC concedes to the non-compliance by the Political Parties: ADR to file a petition in a Court of Law

Putting an end to 22-month-long wait on non-compliance by the six National Political Parties of the 3rd June, 2013 CIC order declaring them as public authorities, the Central Information Commission (CIC) observed in its order dated 16th March 2015 that the RTI Act does not provide the Commission with ample powers to deal with the cases of contempt and non-compliance. The Complaint (CIC/CC/C/2015000182) was filed by Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) along with Mr. Subhash Chandra Aggarwal.
Although CIC did not take any action against the political parties (INC, BJP, BSP, NCP, CPI and CPI-M) on non-compliance, however it has made it clear that its 3rd June 2013 order is “legally correct, and final.” We at ADR firmly believe that RTI Act has sufficient provisions to deal with the cases of non-compliance and contempt of the CIC’s orders.

Please find attached the order of the CIC dated 16th March, 2015. For the background of the case click here.

Highlights of the 16th March, 2015 CIC order:
  • CIC does not have power to implement its orders: CIC states that “the Commission is bereft of the tools to get its orders complied with.”
  • RTI Act has Gaps: CIC says “gaps” in the RTI act relating to the provisions of non-compliance are needed to be addressed.
  • CIC asks DOPT for redressal: CIC sends a copy of the order to the Department of Personnel and Training (DOPT) for taking action to address the legal gaps and issues in order to ensure the compliance of the Commission’s orders.
  • CIC directs complainants (ADR and Mr. Subhash Aggarwal): CIC suggests that “complainants are at liberty, in view of the facts and circumstances of this case, to approach the higher courts for appropriate relief and redressal.”
  • CIC’s Decision that Political Parties are under RTI is binding and final: CIC says that’s its 3rd June 2013 decision of declaring 6 National Political Parties is “binding and final.”
  • CIC stands by its order, 3rd June order is legally correct: Although CIC did not take any action against the parties on-compliance, however CIC has said “Not only is the 3rd June 2013 order “legally correct, it is convincing from the standpoint of the aims and objectives espoused by the RTI Act.”
  • CIC terms Political Parties stand as “wilful”: CIC surmises that “this is an unusual case of wilful non-compliance and highlights the need to identify the legal gap and lacunae in the implementation mechanism.”
ADR’s position
  1. ADR is going to file a petition in the Court asking for action against these 6 National Political Parties for non-compliance and contempt of the 3rd of June 2013 order as well as its implementation.
  2. CIC’s decision that law is silent on non-compliance is not correct. CIC should go by the spirit of the law and not the letter.
  3. Preamble of the RTI act as well the Sections 18, 19 and 20 gives ample powers to CIC to take action on non-compliance by the way of levying fine and awarding compensation, CIC therefore through this order is only abrogating its own power and authority.
  4. CIC is not a court of law. It is only a quasi-judicial body. Therefore, it should not go into the technicalities of the law.
​Regards,

Media and Journalist Helpline

+91 80103 94248
Email: adr@adrindia.org
Maj. Gen. Anil Verma (Retd.)
Head
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
011 4165 4200,
+91 88264 79910
adr@adrIndia.org,
anilverma@adrindia.org
Prof Jagdeep Chhokar
IIM Ahmedabad (Retd.)
Founder Member,
National Election Watch, Association for Democratic
Reforms
+91 99996 20944

Prof Trilochan Sastry
IIM Bangalore
Founder Member,
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
+91 94483 53285
trilochans@iimb.ernet.in


-- 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rouhani wins Iran's Presidential election Moderate cleric Hassan Rouhani won Iran's presidential election on Saturday, the interior ministry said, scoring a surprising landslide victory over conservative hardliners without the need of a second round run-off.Interior minister Mostafa Mohammad-Najjar announced on state television that Rouhani secured just over 50 percent of the ballot based on a 72 percent turnout of 50 million eligible voters. Mr Hassan Rouhani ... got the absolute majority of votes and was elected as president," Najjar said. Tehran Mayor Mohammad-Bagher Ghalibaf, a hard-line conservative, lagged behind with about 16 percent of the votes. Iran's top nuclear negotiator Saeed Jalili, he too a hard-line conservative, earned 11 percent. The voter turnout was 72.7 percent. President-elect Hassan Rohani, sixty four years old, is known as a moderate conservative. He has been stressing the need to improve ties with Western nations, and is back...
Post a Comment
20
Save Dissent to Save Democracy   THE rising instances of physical violence and threats against political opponents and the inability to accept dissent must raise huge concerns amongst all of us who see democracy as perhaps the really stellar achievement since Independence. AAP’s attack on BJP headquarters and acts of arson committed under the very noses of their elite leadership; the attacks on Arvind Kejriwal and Manish Sisodia in Gujarat in the last two days; the recent manhandling of the caretaker of journalist Siddharth Varadarajan’s house by some garden variety thugs; and the violence and threats meted out regularly to their political opponents by political parties is surely deplorable and condemnable. This is a fatally flawed trend which will destroy the very foundations of our democratic institutions if not pushed back with all the strength and condemnation that the civil society can mobilise. Replaying the past To begin with, it must be clarified that we should ...
Post a Comment
20
Discipline Virat can win WCC JUNE 24, 2019 Monsoon in day reach Lucknow Pranati- win the bronze medal M7.3 Earthquake – Banda Sea https://sagarmediainc.com/ INVITATION | LAUNCH OF “SWACHH MAHOTSAVA” CELEBRATIONS BY SH. GAJENDRA SINGH SHEKHAWAT, UNION MINISTER, JAL SHAKTI | 3.45 PM , MONDAY, 24 JUNE | VIGYAN BHAWAN, DELHI Invitation for a discussion on “Emergency: Darkest Hour in Indian Democracy” : S Gurumurthy, Chairman, VIF & Dr A Suryaprakash, Chairman, Prasar Bharti on Monday, 24th June 2019 17.30 NMML Invitation _Dr. Prabha Ravi Shankar_“G.A. Natesan (1873-1949): ‘Old and Dear Friend’ of Mahatma Gandhi”_24 June 2019_3.00pm  CPR and CSH are pleased to invite you to a workshop on ‘Whims of a Digital Boss: The Story of Insecure App-Based Workers in Delhi’ Speaker:  Akriti BhatiaTuesday, 25 June 2019, 3:45 p.m. Centre for Science and Humanities (CSH), 2, Dr APJ Abdul Kalam Road, (formerly Aurangzeb Road) What are the Priorities ...
Post a Comment
20